The future of Estonian healthcare

Join us by brainstorming and contributing your ideas to this platform in order to collectively find new and cross-sectoral solutions to the funding challenges facing the Estonian healthcare system

All ideas37

Prevention

Health is often shaped outside the healthcare system. As a society, if we know that we cannot cope with rising healthcare costs for various reasons, and at the same time, evidence-based prevention as a field is underutilized, we must also make use of this underutilized area systematically, purposefully, and thoughtfully. Prevention is cheaper than dealing with consequences, and there are many opportunities to create a health-supporting environment, but it requires commitment and adequate resources.

P
Pille Third sector

Additional suggestions

H
Helle
Ennetus jaguneb tegelikult kaheks: Enne lapse sündi ning peale lapse sündi kuni vanurini ja lahkumine siit ilmast. Üks elutsükkel, millele mõeldakse siiani vaid tagajärgedele. Teine ennetuse pool kuulub meditsiinitöötajaks ettevalmistav perjoodi. Eesti teadusliku meditsiini tööpraktika osakaal peaks kuuluma iga indiviidi personaalsele ravile. Ettevalmistada uuringu katserühmad, mis hõlmavad individuaalse ravi põhimõtteid ja võrrelda eesti kogukonna gruppide ravi põhimõtetega. Siit selguvad meie meditsiinilise ravi kitsaskohad.
KK
Külliki Kristianson

The National Health Development Plan 2020–2030 has as one of its sub-goals the promotion of a health-supporting environment and recognizes that the negative effects of environmental factors may often only manifest years later (for example, the development of allergies, nerve damage, or tumors). However, many doctors today still do not know the causes of these damages, and unfortunately, they cannot be treated with pills.

The Cancer Control Action Plan 2021–2030, in the chapter on Primary Cancer Prevention, lists risk factors that are not given sufficient attention in practice, if at all: ‘The main cancer-causing factors in the physical environment are ultraviolet radiation (UV radiation), RADON, environmental tobacco smoke, and fine particles in outdoor and indoor air, EXPOSURE TO VARIOUS CARCINOGENS FROM PRODUCTS, as well as contaminants and additives related to food cultivation, handling, and preparation.’

The same action plan further highlights: ‘The ability to measure chemical substances present in work and living environments is limited. Information collected from various fields on risk factors arising from the living environment must be integrated and used to assess the total exposure of individuals, to develop interventions for reducing exposure, and to shape a health-supporting living and working environment.’

This complex statement means that we need to organize air quality measurements, product evaluations, and bio-monitoring of people, and compare these results. After all, science and evidence-based approaches are of the utmost importance! But these crucial preventive actions have remained undone for reasons unknown.

Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) emitted from products are not only carcinogenic but also neurotoxic, which has wreaked havoc on the mental health of the population. For example, formaldehyde is both carcinogenic and neurotoxic; additionally, it is a cause of all cardiovascular diseases, and relevant scientific research is freely available on all research platforms. And it is emitted from everyday consumer items such as foam and polyester mattresses and pillows, particle board, etc., which means we have all been exposed to them far too much. Product safety supervision is absolutely necessary!

If a patient goes to the doctor today with a chronic cough, does the doctor know to check if the patient is not living in a radon-rich area?

Unfortunately, the name change at the Health Insurance Fund has not led to any substantive change in its work; it continues to fund only disease treatment but not health. If the Health Insurance Fund does not start funding the important preventive activities outlined in health development plans, no improvement in public health can be expected. Next year, will there be 150 million missing from the budget? Treatment is not only expensive but also painful; a sick person cannot work or is not effective enough, and the planned tax increase is not feasible and only adds unnecessary stress. Therefore, let’s please invest in prevention instead.

I
Ingrid

Addition for Peeter!

Prevention is a strategic plan aimed at either achieving something or avoiding something.

Here are some examples from other fields, though it is similar in the health sector as well, meaning it requires a strategic plan and an identification of risk and protective factors.

An example from another field (which is also somewhat related to health): How is fire prevented? The risk factors that most commonly cause fires are identified, and then efforts are made to eliminate or mitigate these risk factors. Additionally, factors that prevent risks—protective factors—are identified and strengthened.

Examples: a smoke detector as a risk-mitigating factor, old electrical wiring as a risk-causing factor. Preventing a fire is cheaper than dealing with the aftermath of a fire (lost property, property restoration, health and life, rescue resources are still needed, etc.).

As Pille mentioned, health is shaped outside of healthcare, so we must focus on where a person’s health is formed: kindergarten, school, home, workplace, local government, etc.

I
Ingrid

I support Pille’s ideas!

There is a lot of talk about how raising awareness is necessary to achieve change, and that this will lead us to make better decisions. Awareness has been a focus for several decades and must continue to be so. Awareness is important, but it alone is not enough to bring about change.

To create change, we need to influence social norms. Social norms are a set of unwritten and written rules and expectations that guide our behavior throughout society. These norms determine what behaviors or actions have gained widespread acceptance in our society and which have not, thus influencing people’s decisions, actions, mindsets, and attitudes.

In a society where valuing health goes beyond the individual level (i.e., it is a social norm) and where health promotion is recognized as an essential part of a successful country’s development in all sectors, a healthy lifestyle is significantly more widespread and supported. This means that every member of society has a role and responsibility. All members of society benefit from this as well—healthier people can contribute much more to the development and well-being of society. Moreover, the fewer people who end up in the healthcare system (due to prevented illnesses), the more resources the state has to direct towards supporting the country’s development, thus improving the well-being of everyone.

Example: For instance, the private sector values employee health (employees spend most of their day at work) and adopts proven measures, such as encouraging regular movement during the workday in sedentary jobs.

Example: The food industry plans or modifies existing recipes to be health-supportive (based on evidence-based information), etc.

Example: Local communities actively participate and contribute to health-promoting activities in their areas.

Example: Local governments support local communities that contribute to evidence-based health promotion activities.

Simple Choices: People make choices that are easy for them to make. If healthy choices are the easier and socially favored/supported options, then people will make them. Unhealthy choices should be inconvenient and difficult so that they are made much less frequently. For example, access to alcohol should be inconvenient and moderately expensive so that people are less likely to buy it.

Healthy choices should be the simplest choices for individuals, as people often base their daily actions on what offers quick solutions in terms of time and money, and on what the social norm is.

A
Aljona

According to the Population Health Development Plan 2020-2030, the main risk factors for diseases are an unbalanced diet, tobacco consumption, air pollution, excessive alcohol consumption and insufficient physical activity. I support Pille’s thoughts. The development plan can be found here: https://www.sm.ee/rahvastiku-tervise-arengukava-2020-2030

P
Pille

And here we can actually bring up a very effective and proven example of prevention, which is vaccination. If we look at prevention as something aimed at averting potential issues, vaccination has, over decades, prevented a great many deaths and health complications.

Tõnu Mertsina previously mentioned that “quality healthcare is one of the cornerstones of a successful economy. If it keeps Estonians as healthy as possible and extends their healthy life years and life expectancy, it helps to improve and maintain the most important part of society—human capital.” We can say exactly the same about prevention. I would even argue that it is largely a part of successful economic policy and a crucial aspect of a better and more successful future outlook.

Let’s also consider mental health. According to the WHO definition, mental health is a state of well-being that enables a person to 1) realize their potential, 2) cope with the stresses of everyday life, and 3) work productively and contribute to society. The current state and future projections of mental health are no secret. And I ask, can healthcare alone solve this complex problem? Estonia needs healthier people who don’t fall into the trap of illness too early, and we need to think broadly and strategically about how to maintain human capital as an actual capital and a productive part of society. If too many people shift too early from being contributors to becoming dependents, it raises significant concerns for everyone. We all want Estonia to have a future, perspective, and hope as a society. One of the fundamental pillars of this is a healthy population. And to keep people “as healthy as possible for as long as possible,” various measures must be implemented. One part of this is healthcare, another part is prevention. And certainly, there are third, fourth, and fifth parts, etc. But what can be prevented must be prevented. We are too poor to massively treat problems that are largely preventable. Yes, not everything can be prevented, and not everyone can be saved, but we can definitely make significant progress in this area.

P
Pille

Hello Peeter and everyone else! I agree that prevention is complex and time-consuming, which can make it seem less effective. However, this doesn’t mean that the field is in any way insignificant. It certainly extends beyond traditional healthcare, but the outcomes still have a significant impact on healthcare. If there’s a lack of consistency and systematization, and if the subject is understood differently by various stakeholders, then indeed, it becomes challenging, and results are scarce. But this isn’t the fault of prevention as a concept; rather, the problem lies in systemic choices and decisions.

In prevention (and I’m speaking broadly here), we can, for example, shape alcohol policies, implement various parenting programs, and introduce initiatives in educational institutions (like the “Liikuma Kutsuv Kool” program, KiVa, etc.). My position largely stems from the belief that if this field doesn’t receive more focus, we can’t expect good results from it.

I’d also like to ask, Peeter, what speaks against prevention? I agree that there are issues, but is the problem within prevention itself or rather in its implementation? What could help make prevention more effective? Should prevention be entirely left out? I think we’re not yet seeing the full impact on healthcare of the direction we’re heading, but these effects will hit us hard later on. For example, obesity, children’s dental health, mental health issues, and so on.

P
Peeter

Could you, Pille, provide examples where effective prevention can be applied?

Click to initialize TinyMCE

Recently added ideas

  • Supported 1
  • Don't believe in the idea 0

7 thoughts about the healthcare sector’s main problems

  1. Health concerns are not solved by the healthcare sector alone in the big picture, but rather by the economic success of society and the understanding at all levels of society that investing in health is worthwhile.
  2. Considering the current state of healthcare in Estonia, the idea of a mega-hospital …
  • Supported 13
  • Don't believe in the idea 10

Emergency services for a fee

My recommendation would be to make ambulance services paid. Since I work in the ambulance service in Tallinn, I see how many calls are not emergencies but rather a convenience service. It's easy to call 112, and three staff members come and give paracetamol – people have no sense of …
  • Supported 12
  • Don't believe in the idea 7

Three years of mandatory work in Estonian healthcare

A significant part of the shortage of doctors is due to the fact that they go abroad to work after graduating. The shortage of nurses, on the other hand, is caused by the fact that they move to the private sector, for example, to aesthetic medicine. If a requirement were …
All ideas
Developed by Ballers